Portfolio decisions · New contributions
Rebalancing with new money: a complete worked case
Compare buying underweight holdings with buying at target weights. See whole-share rounding, fees and cash left over before deciding.
Original method · Reproducible examplesStart with a decision, not a ticker list
You have 10,000 invested and another 1,000 to add. Your chosen target is 60% in an equity basket, 30% in a bond basket and 10% in a diversifier. The current values are 7,000, 2,000 and 1,000. The equity basket is already above target. Sending 60% of the next deposit into it follows the target for new money, but does not restore the target for the whole portfolio.
The useful question is: how much of this deposit can close the allocation gap without selling anything? These fictional buckets illustrate a method. They do not prescribe a portfolio, identify actual funds or estimate returns.
1. Put every input on the same basis
Use current market values and prices measured in one reporting currency at a consistent time. Cost basis answers a tax question; it does not describe today's allocation. If you hold foreign assets, convert their values and prices first. Exclude emergency savings and money already committed elsewhere from the deposit. Existing uninvested cash is not modeled separately: include only the cash you deliberately want this plan to allocate.
For the worked case, use prices of 100, 50 and 25, no fees, and whole-share purchases. These prices are chosen for arithmetic, not taken from a market feed.
2. Calculate dollar shortfalls after the deposit
Target values = 6,600 / 3,300 / 1,100
Positive shortfalls = 0 / 1,300 / 100
The total positive shortfall is 1,400, but only 1,000 is available. The planner splits that 1,000 in the ratio 1,300:100. Before share rounding, the budgets are 928.57 and 71.42; the remaining cent stays cash. A budget is a ceiling, not a promise to spend the whole amount.
| Bucket | Buy units | Buy amount | After value | After weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Equity basket | 0 | 0 | 7,000 | 63.64% |
| Bond basket | 18 | 900 | 2,900 | 26.36% |
| Diversifier | 2 | 50 | 1,050 | 9.55% |
| Unallocated cash | — | — | 50 | 0.45% |
The cash check is 1,000 = 950 purchased + 0 fees + 50 left. No stock is sold, and nothing is borrowed.
3. Compare with buying the target weights
A 60/30/10 split of the deposit buys 600, 300 and 100. Final holdings become 7,600, 2,300 and 1,100, or 69.09%, 20.91% and 10%. The equity overweight barely changes.
We define allocation gap as half the sum of absolute percentage-point differences from each target, including unallocated cash with a target of zero. This makes retained cash visible. In this example, the gap moves from 10.00 points to 4.09 with shortfall-directed purchases, versus 9.09 with target-weight purchases. It is a distance measure, not a risk score. Two funds with similar labels can still hold overlapping securities.
4. Test the cost and rounding trade-off
Change the fixed order fee to 2. The planner reserves 6 for three possible orders, leaving 994 for the allocation calculation. Only the bond and diversifier orders execute, so actual fees are 4. The unused 2 returns to residual cash: 1,000 = 950 purchased + 4 fees + 46 left.
This deliberately conservative reserve makes the calculation deterministic. It may leave cash that a different combination of trades could invest. The tool does not search all combinations, calculate percentage commissions, estimate spreads, account for taxes or guarantee an optimal allocation. For fractional purchases, it allocates cents; the displayed share count still needs checking against your broker's fraction rules.
5. Know when a deposit is too small
Ignoring fees and share rounding, keeping the 7,000 equity holding at a 60% target requires a total portfolio of at least 7,000 ÷ 0.60 = 11,666.67, rounded up to cents. That means at least 1,666.67 of total new cash. The 1,000 deposit is insufficient to reach all targets exactly. A positive holding with a zero target cannot be eliminated with any finite cash contribution.
This is a feasibility threshold, not a suggestion to invest more. If your available deposit is smaller, you can knowingly accept residual drift. Selling, revising targets and waiting for future deposits are different decisions with different costs.
6. Keep a decision record
Download the inputs and results before changing assumptions. Record why you chose the targets, when prices were observed, which fees were excluded and what would cause a future review. After actual fills, compare purchased values and residual cash with the plan. The exported CSV contains both allocation methods; the JSON preserves inputs and formula version. Neither is an order file.
Run this case in the planner → · Explore long-term contribution assumptions
Sources and boundaries
The SEC's Investor.gov guide to asset allocation and rebalancing describes directing contributions toward underweight categories and considering costs. Our proportional-shortfall allocation rule, fee reserve, examples and comparison metric are original implementation choices; the SEC does not endorse this calculator.
Source checked 2026-11-06. Arithmetic examples are reproducible, synthetic scenarios. This is education and planning support, not personalized investment, tax or trading advice.